The New Yorker’s Guide to Broadway: See a Show Like a Local

Broadway is on bucket lists around the world — and for good reason. Even New Yorkers can’t resist the thrill of world-class performances, the spectacle, and the glamor of the bright lights of Broadway.

Whether you’re a theater lover or haven’t seen a production since high school, my quick guide goes over everything you need to know: what to expect, where to eat, and how to plan the perfect night in one of New York’s most famous neighborhoods. 

What is Broadway?

Broadway means a lot of things to a lot of people, but there is an official Broadway definition. The term “Broadway” refers to 41 professional theaters located in and around the Times Square area, also called the Theater District. If a theater seats more than 500 people, it’s considered Broadway.   

The History of Broadway

What makes Broadway special isn’t just the sets, orchestras, and dazzling costumes — it’s the history. Broadway’s history stretches back nearly 300 years, with New York City’s first recorded professional theater performance (The Recruiting Officer) in 1732. As the city grew, so did its theater scene, gradually moving north and settling around what we now know as Times Square in the early 20th century. 

Broadway has evolved over hundreds of years. While I love a good long-running classic, it’s also fun to try new musicals, witty revivals, and interesting plays that reflect modern culture. Whether you want a big, joyful musical or something more intimate and thought-provoking, there’s something for everyone on Broadway. For instance, currently there is a thoughtful production of the Greek Tragedy, Oedipus, featuring British stars of stage and screen Mark Strong and Lesley Manville, alongside the thrilling and long-running musical Moulin Rouge.  There is something for everyone on Broadway.  

How to Choose a Broadway Show

If you’re new to Broadway, choosing the right show can feel overwhelming. Here are a few tips to keep in mind:

• Play vs musical: Musicals tend to be bigger, louder, and more spectacle-driven. Plays are usually shorter, more dialogue-focused, and great if you want something sharp, emotional, or intellectually stimulating.
• Buzz matters: New Yorkers tend to follow word-of-mouth. If you keep hearing the same show mentioned in group chats or at dinner, it’s probably a good choice.
• Check out what people are saying online: Reddit and online forums like Broadway World and Talkin’ Broadway are great resources for getting real reviews from real people.
• Mood check: Want to laugh at life’s absurdity, cry during a tragic story, or experience the thrill of choreography and a big band? Pick a show based on how you want to feel walking out of the theater.
• Don’t fall for celebrity: Big-name actors can be a draw, but don’t overlook shows without famous faces. Many of Broadway’s best performances come from fresh or little-known cast members, many on their way up to stardom.

Pro-tip: For help picking seats and for often better pricing, go to the theater box office (even on the day of the show). Sometimes, they’ll help you avoid ticketing services and fees. Keep in mind that shows aren’t just for the weekends — often weeknight shows have more availability, better seats, and better pricing (particularly on Tuesdays and Wednesdays). 

Here’s a link to the Broadway schedule so you can see a list of all Broadway shows running right now.
 

Top Broadway Shows

If you’re feeling overwhelmed choosing what to see, these long-running shows are usually a safe bet (just be prepared to pay a bit more for these big-name productions):

• Oh Mary!  (The current star, James Cameron Mitchell, performed at The Terrace and Outdoor Gardens)
• Hamilton
• Moulin Rouge
• Aladdin
• The Book of Mormon
• Wicked

Where to Get Broadway Tickets

There are lots of ways to get tickets, but I’ve learned a few tricks over the years. Ticketing services are convenient and easy to use, but they are often the most expensive.

• Official box offices:  As mentioned, buying directly from theaters can help you avoid extra fees, and for me, it also adds to the experience 
• Digital lotteries and rush tickets: Apps like TodayTix and Broadway Direct often offer discounted same-day or next-day tickets. Plus, TodayTix members get dining perks at The Terrace and Outdoor Gardens when you use the code EDITION20 on your first ticket purchase.
• TKTS Booth: Waiting in line at these booths is well worth it (located at Lincoln Center and Times Square) to get same-day or next-day tickets at half price.
  • Note: Really popular shows like The Lion King or Wicked typically won’t be available at TKTS booths due to high demand.
• Third-party sites: Probably the most convenient and easiest is utilizing sites like third-party websites such as  Ticketmaster, SeatGeek, and StubHub. Just be ready to pay their famous service fees.
• Be wary of resellers: Always double-check before you buy. There are lots of sites out there that look official but aren’t. If you’re not sure, go directly to the show’s official website and look for the "Buy Tickets" button — it will redirect you to the authorized reseller.
• Explore special discounts and promotions: Some theaters give discounts to students and military members, and run limited-time promos. 
• Take advantage of memberships: Join certain groups like Will Call Club or become a member at TDF — you may just snag some pretty serious savings. 

What are the Best Seats for a Broadway Show?

Knowing where to sit at a Broadway show isn’t easy because it all depends on the theater. One of the most magical things about Broadway is its unique history, but that also means each theater comes with its own quirks. 

Generally speaking, the sweet spot is Center Orchestra (rows 5–10). You’re close enough to see the actors' expressions but far enough back to take in the full stage and all the spectacle.

If you’re splurging on front row seats, you’re in for an awesome time (you’ll get to see the actor’s pit and catch some of the impressive costume changes). Just keep in mind that you might be craning your neck and may miss some of the bigger picture — especially at theaters like the Gerald Schoenfeld, which has a really high stage.

When it comes to balcony seating, what you’ll get varies a lot by theater. For example, the Lyceum Theatre has two balconies. Balcony seating can be great, but just keep in mind that rear balcony seats tend to be the worst seats in the house. 

Pro-tip: Use A View from My Seat to get a quick sense of what your view might be from certain areas. 

Broadway Etiquette & Basics Everyone Should Know

Whether it’s your first time to Broadway or you’re just out of practice, keep these rules in mind:

• Get there early: When deciding how early to arrive at a Broadway show, aim to get there  30 minutes early so you can be seated 15 minutes before curtain. 
• No talking or texting: Even the lowest light on your phone is distracting, and yes, even whispering carries.
• Turn your notifications off: Broadway ushers mean business. When they say silence your phone, they mean it.
• Do not take photos: Using your camera for photos or videos is a big no-no. 
• Stay seated during scenes: Save exits for intermission unless absolutely necessary.
• Use intermission wisely: Use the restroom before the show or immediately at intermission. Just be prepared for long lines. 
• Don’t sing along: As tempting as it may be to belt your favorite tunes, don’t sing along or dance to the music. 
• Applause is encouraged: You don’t need to be an expert in theater performances. If it feels impressive, clap! If you’re moved to a louder and more vocal “whoop,” only do so during moments of loud applause. 
   

Pro-tip: If you hear chimes while you’re at the bar, that’s your two-minute warning. Take your drink with you to your seat if the theater allows — most do, and you can often get a production-themed souvenir cup to bring home with you. Once those doors close, you’ll be stuck watching on the lobby monitor.
 

Is There a Broadway Dress Code?

There’s no official dress code at Broadway shows. You can wear anything from jeans and sneakers to cocktail dresses and blazers. Just apply the New Yorker rule: wear something comfortable, polished, and weather-appropriate. The sweet spot? Think “nice night out.” 

Where to Eat Before a Broadway Show

There are lots of options in the area, but many are tourist-oriented and don’t offer the best dining experience. At The Times Square EDITION Hotel,  The Terrace & Outdoor Gardens is an American brasserie where your pre-theater dinner will feel just as magical as the show. Located steps from the theater district, we take Broadway dining to a new level and transport you to a romantic indoor garden oasis with lush greenery, warm lighting, and an intimate vibe.

Our iconic restaurant is a favorite for audiences and actors alike. In fact, you might even spot some familiar faces. With the Palace Theater right across the street, the cast of Beetlejuice popped over and joined us for a roundtable event with food, drinks, and discussions about the magic of the stage. 

Reserve the Broadway Express Dinner, an elegant three-course prix fixe menu specifically designed for theater-goers, for only $68 per person. It’s a great way to ensure a delicious Broadway dining experience and stay on schedule. 

Pro-tip: Plan to leave about 45-60 minutes before curtain, depending on which theater you’re going to
 

Looking for a show after the show? See if Paradise Club, an iconic NYC nightclub and event venue, is hosting an event. Think cabaret, comedy, live music, nightlife, and more — all in a unique setting with some of the most beautiful murals you’ve ever seen. 

Plan Your Perfect Night on Broadway

Broadway doesn’t have to be overpriced or touristy. With this Broadway guide and a little planning, it’s one of the best ways to spend an evening in New York City.

The Terrace & Outdoor Gardens makes it easy to plan the perfect night. The Broadway Express Dinner is great for theater-goers, available from 4:30-10 PM every day — so you can swing by for a late dinner after the show as well. Prefer a quick drink? Check out the Lobby Bar for some of the best cocktails in Times Square.

Broadway FAQs 

We’ve answered some of the most common questions for you, so you’re not stuck Googling on the way to the theater.

Where is Broadway in New York?

Most Broadway theaters are located in Midtown Manhattan, clustered around Times Square. Despite the name, many theaters are not actually on the street called Broadway. 

Do Broadway shows start on time?

Yes, Broadway shows generally start on time, which means exactly what’s printed on your ticket. 

How early should you arrive for a Broadway show?

If you’re not sure how early to arrive for a Broadway show, aim to arrive 30 minutes before curtain and be seated at least 15 minutes early. Latecomers may not be seated immediately, and trust me — you really don’t want to miss the opening scenes. 

How long is a Broadway show?

While it varies by show, Broadway performances typically run 2 to 2.5 hours (including intermission). Plays tend to be slightly shorter than musicals, but always check the runtime before booking if you’re on a tight schedule.

How long is the intermission on Broadway?

Intermission is usually 15 minutes. It’s just long enough to stretch your legs, use the restroom, and debate Act I.

What do you wear to a Broadway show?

There’s no official dress code for Broadway shows, but think polished and comfortable.

How many theaters are on Broadway?

There are 41 Broadway theaters currently recognized by the Broadway League. 

What’s the difference between Broadway and Off-Broadway shows?

Chances are you’ve heard of Broadway vs Off-Broadway. Here’s what it means:

• Broadway: 500+ seats, large-scale productions, higher budgets
• Off-Broadway: 100–499 seats, often more experimental or intimate